Day 9 | America Feels Broken to Me

Today’s Readings

“Do to others whatever you would have them do to you.
This is the law and the prophets.” [Matthew 7:12]

America feels broken to me. As a child who grew up living in different countries while being educated in American schools, the United States was the standard, the ideal. It was the aspiration; a country where democracy flourished and everyone had equal rights…or so I thought.

Thirty years later, I find myself wondering why this country of dreams and opportunities isn’t showing more compassion for the plight of refugees and immigrants, why there are so many black and brown people in jails, why otherwise good, God-loving Americans are blind to the racial inequality that pervades in education, housing, healthcare, lending practices, and in our courts. For me, as it should be for all of us who call America home, it is imperative to remember and reflect on the abundance and generosity of the country that educated me, allowed me to pursue my dreams, and welcomed me as an immigrant. I now need to fight so that all others can have access to the same.

This moral mandate found in today’s Gospel has become my reason to be. I left the classroom after two decades to help develop schools where diversity is valued, and equality is not confused for equity. I sit on the board of Educators for Social Justice, whose mission is “to develop and support socially just, equitable, and sustainable practices in schools and communities.” I now proudly claim my identity as a person of color and use my Hispanic heritage and my ease in navigating white spaces to build bridges among races. I read books that broaden my perspectives; The Hate U Give, The Tears We Cannot Stop: A Sermon to White America, and White Kids: Growing Up with Privilege in a Racially Divided America, currently sit on my nightstand.

I now implore that you do the same. Reflect on the country that welcomed you or your ancestors, open your eyes to its brokenness and begin (or continue) your journey of cultural competence so that you can speak up and fight against the injustices that are closing in around us. We need to find the humanity that connects us to heal what is broken.

7 replies
  1. Francesca Thomas
    Francesca Thomas says:

    Your reflection completely resonated with me. I too, for some time, have felt like the America I grew up and believed in is broken. I have come to learn that it has been broken for some time; I just wasn’t aware. Now, with eyes wide open, I can better commit to the one of the two Great Commandments, to love one another as Christ loved us. May God grant peace in our day and may we, with all the gifts and talents with which we have been bestowed, work tirelessly to build a world that reflects the goodness of God.

  2. Parvin Johnson
    Parvin Johnson says:

    This is a very earnest message that reached inside my heart. I pray that your prayers join with mine that I join in your effort to bring about these critical changes.

  3. Suzanne Hesh
    Suzanne Hesh says:

    America was born broken. We’ve never, as a nation, confessed, lamented, or made reparations to the people on whom we inflicted pain and suffering and degraded. In our founding documents, women and indigenous people are not mentioned and slaves are considered. 3/5 human. We need to start over, not attempt incremental reforms.

  4. Joan Mistretta
    Joan Mistretta says:

    Well, first I’ll say why I shouldn’t be writing this comment, then I guess I’ll do it anyway just to get it off my chest. I shouldn’t write it because my reason may be considered frivolous and anyway you can’t do anything about the title of a book already published. But I can’t think why in the world a serious author would choose to use “U” instead of “You” in a book title. Totally turns me off and I bet a lot of other people too. Thanks.

    • Madeline Powers
      Madeline Powers says:

      There is a story behind that title – it’s an acronym for THUG. It wouldn’t work otherwise. I highly recommend watching the movie or reading the book. (Though beware, it’s definitely for a young adult audience and lacks nuance in some cases.) It’s powerful. The students who participated in the viewing at our school were not sure what they had signed up for but were glad they did.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *